THE Supreme Court ruled that open spaces and road lots inside subdivisions don’t automatically become government property without a written deed of donation.
In a decision penned by Associate Justice Jhosep Lopez, the Court’s Second Division affirmed that the Quezon City government failed to prove ownership of common areas in Capital Park Homes Subdivision (CPHS).
Court rules on subdivision open spaces, road lots, This news data comes from:http://aichuwei.com
The case stemmed from a petition filed by Rainier Madrid, a Quezon City taxpayer and resident of a nearby subdivision, who questioned the use of public funds to improve the CPHS properties. He argued that developer VV Soliven never executed a deed of donation transferring the areas to the city, which made them private rather than public property.
While the city government cited a 1964 ordinance that required subdivision developers to allocate 6 percent of their land for public use before plan approval, the Court stressed that compliance with the ordinance doesn’t replace the legal requirement of a written donation.
The Capital Park Homeowners Association admitted there was no deed of donation but pointed to a board resolution acknowledging the supposed turnover. The Regional Trial Court initially dismissed Madrid’s petition for lack of standing, but the Court of Appeals reversed the ruling, finding merit in his challenge.
Court rules on subdivision open spaces, road lots
The Supreme Court upheld the appellate court, ruling that local governments must show a valid transfer of property through a deed of donation and proof of acceptance under the Civil Code. Without such documents, ownership remains with the subdivision developer.
”The donation of subdivision land to a local government unit must be in writing for ownership to be transferred,” the Court said, reiterating that local ordinances alone can’t establish government ownership.
- Police brutality fuels soaring tensions in Indonesia
- Cebu Pacific to launch direct flights between Cebu and Palawan
- Searchers retrieve bodies as Afghan quake toll seen to rise
- Harold Cabreros takes post as new OCD chief
- Ballots for oct 13 BARMM polls completed – Comelec
- Israel flattens high-rise as it tells Gaza City residents to flee
- CFO moves office from QC to Pasay
- NBI slaps Alice Guo, 35 Others with new graft, misconduct cases
- House panel defers 2026 DPWH budget until agency submits changes
- Indonesian finance minister's home looted as protest anger grows
